Care Managed Vs Self-Managed Home Care Packages

Getting started with home care can be both daunting and empowering, so the more research you can do, the better!

Whether you’re exploring options for yourself or a loved one, one of the important considerations to understand is the distinctions between care managed and self-managed home care packages.

In today’s world, where independence and quality of life are paramount, finding the right approach to home care can make all the difference in maintaining autonomy and receiving the support you need.

So, in this blog, let’s examine the differences between these two options and explore which one might be the best fit for you or your loved one’s unique set of circumstances and health needs.

Understanding home care

Home care represents a wide range of services designed to assist individuals with various daily activities and healthcare needs within the comfort of their own homes. These services can include assistance with personal care, medication management, meal preparation, household chores, transportation, companionship, and even specialised medical care. The goal of home care is to enhance your quality of life while promoting independence and safety, allowing you to access the care you need, the way you want to receive it. 

To learn more, read our comprehensive suite of blogs examining home care services in Australia, including more information on the types of services that packages can be used toward. 

In Australia, all home care packages require an approved provider to provide the client with oversight of the package. This is so your care services cater to your changing requirements, as well as ensure they comply with the national standards and legislation. 

In a care managed plan, the provider plays a more significant role in coordinating care and services under your home care package. In contrast, in a self-managed plan you have greater control of the choices and decisions related to your care. You may also take a more active role in completing your care plan, budget, identifying and reaching out to care workers, and appraising your services. 

It’s important to note that not every provider offers self-managed home care packages, so if this option is of interest to you or your loved one, you’ll need to choose and engage with a relevant provider. 

Care managed home care packages

Care managed home care packages involve engaging a professional care provider to coordinate and deliver the necessary services according to your assessed care needs. With this option, the chosen care provider assumes responsibility for managing your care plan, arranging suitable caregivers, and ensuring continuity of care. They handle administrative tasks, such as scheduling, payroll, and compliance with regulations, relieving you of the logistical burdens. 

One of the primary advantages of care managed packages is the expertise and experience that providers bring to the table. They employ trained professionals who understand the intricacies of aged care, ensuring that you receive high-quality, reliable assistance.  

Additionally, care managed packages offer a streamlined process, providing you with access to a network of caregivers and resources tailored to your needs.

Self-managed home care packages

On the other hand, self-managed home care packages empower you to take control of your care journey by directly managing your allocated funds and selecting your caregivers. With this option, you have the flexibility to choose who provides your care, when they provide it, and how it is delivered. Self-management fosters a sense of autonomy and independence, allowing you to completely customise your care plan according to your preferences and priorities. 

As a result, self-managed packages offer greater flexibility and choice, enabling you to hire caregivers who align with your values and preferences. For example, you have the freedom to engage care workers, set schedules, and tailor services to meet your evolving needs.  

Moreover, self-management encourages a greater active involvement in your care, fostering a sense of empowerment and self-determination.

Pros & Cons

Both care managed and self-managed home care packages offer unique advantages, catering to different preferences and circumstances.  

Care managed packages provide peace of mind and convenience, relieving you of administrative tasks and ensuring professional oversight. They are particularly beneficial for individuals who like to be engaged in the decision-making around their care but also prefer a hands-off approach or require specialised care that necessitates professional expertise. 

On the other hand, self-managed packages offer flexibility and control, allowing you to personalise your care experience according to your preferences and lifestyle. They are ideal for individuals who value autonomy and want to oversee the entire decision-making process regarding their care – however, this can come with a significant administrative obligation that many find challenging to maintain.

Case Study 1: Margaret’s journey

Margaret, a retiree with mild cognitive impairment, opted for a care managed home care package to ensure consistent support and supervision. With the assistance of a reputable provider, Margaret received personalised care tailored to her cognitive needs, including medication reminders, housekeeping and gardening support, and companionship. The professional oversight provided by the care manager gave Margaret’s family peace of mind, knowing that she was in capable hands. 

Case Study 2: John’s experience

John, a retiree living with a progressive disability, chose a self-managed home care package to retain complete control over his care journey. By directly managing his allocated funds, John was able to hire caregivers who shared his interests and values, fostering meaningful connections and companionship. The flexibility of self-management allowed John to maintain his independence and dignity, empowering him to live life on his own terms.

The role of providers in enhancing care

While self-management offers autonomy and flexibility, you should also recognise the valuable role that providers play in delivering high-quality care while also including you in the home care process. 

As part of their support to you through care managed home care, providers act as partners in your wellbeing journey, offering expertise, and resources to ensure optimal outcomes. By collaborating with your provider, you can still actively participate in decision-making, voice your preferences, and advocate for your needs, desires and future aspirations and health goals. Therefore, here at Respect, we offer fully managed home care packages to our clients — chat with our team anytime and quiz us on what makes us different.

Providers strive to create a collaborative care environment where your input is valued and respected. They welcome feedback, suggestions, and concerns, continuously striving to improve and adapt to your evolving needs. 

By fostering open communication and partnership, providers empower you to play an active role in shaping your care experience while benefiting from their professional support and guidance. 

In summary

In navigating the complexities of home care, understanding the differences between care managed and self-managed packages is crucial. Whether you prioritise convenience and oversight or value flexibility and autonomy, there’s a home care option tailored to your preferences and needs. By weighing the advantages and benefits of each approach and collaborating with your provider, you can embark on a care journey that enhances your wellbeing, independence, and quality of life.

We’re here to support you

While Respect Home Care does not offer self-managed home care options, we do provide a commitment to all of our clients, to support each and every one of them with the highest level of person-centred care.

Ready to receive hassle-free in-home care support? Grab our free report for a step-by-step guide to accessing a Home Care Package (HCP), understanding costs, switching providers and a must-have handy home care checklist.

Got questions or like to receive more support? Please reach our care at home advisors or call us on 1300 144 144 and choose “home care” as a service option.